Radeon HD 6970 vs. R9 280X - Should I upgrade?
Category : Should I Upgrade?
Published by Marc Büchel on 27.01.14
A gamer simply can't get enough graphics power in their rig, which makes the upgrade question omnipresent. To show you whether it makes sense to upgrade from one generation to another we created this series of articles, where we will compare graphics cards from different generations. Today we're having a close look at the differences between the Radeon HD 6970 and the R9 280X.



  Article in English   Artikel in Deutsch   Article en français   Articolo in italiano




Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Test Setup

Hardware

Mainboard
  • ASUS Maximus V Gene (BIOS 1802)
CPUs
  • Intel Core i7-3770K @ 4.0 GHz (Turbo On / HT On)
Memory
  • G.Skill Ares Dual Channel 2x8GB @ CL11-13-13-31-1T-Auto DDR3-2400 MHz
Graphic Cards (Driver)
  • AMD Radeon R9 280X
  • AMD Radeon HD 6970
Drivers
  • Windows 7 x64 (up to date)
  • NVIDIA ForceWare 331.40 Beta
  • AMD Catalyst 13.11 BetaV1
  • Intel Chipset Driver 9.4.0.1026
Games and OS
  • Windows 7 x64 (Up to date on the ) 01/10/2013
  • All games were up to date on the 01/10/2013
HDD
  • OCZ Technology Octane 512 GB SSD
PSU
  • Seasonic Platinum SS-1000XP / 1000 Watts



Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

3DMark - Fire Strike Performance





Total Score Score Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 7'093 189.55 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 3'742 100.00 %
     
Graphics Score Score Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 7'837 201.98 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 3'880 100.00 %
More is better





3DMark - Fire Strike Extreme





 
Total Score Score Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 3'564 199.78 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 1'784 100.00 %
     
Graphics Score Score Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 3'668 208.41 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 1'760 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Unigine Heaven 4.0 Extreme Preset





Total Score Score Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 1113 179.52 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 620 100.00 %
     
Frames per second FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 44.2 179.47 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 24.6 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

BattleField 3





High Preset, 1920x1080, 4xMSAA, Ultra, SSAO FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 76.6 214.00 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 35.8 100.00 %
More is better






Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Borderlands 2





High Preset, 1920x1080, FXAA, no PhsyX, High FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 112.8 150.00 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 75.2 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Bioshock Infinite - Benchmark





Ultra Preset, 1920x1080, AA, no DDOF FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 75.44 174.63 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 43.20 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Crysis 3





High Preset, 1920x1080, 8xMSAA, Very High FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 19.4 132.88 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 14.6 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Call of Duty Black Ops 2





High Preset, 1920x1080, 8xMSAA, High FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 102.8 149.85 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 68.6 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

DIRT Showdown - Benchmark





High Preset, 1920x1080, 8xMSAA, Ultra FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 76.46 173.03 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 44.19 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Far Cry 3





High Preset, 1920x1080, 8xMSAA, Ultra FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 30.0 145.63 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 20.6 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Sleeping Dogs - Benchmark





High Preset, 1920x1080, Extreme, High-Res Textures FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 50.7 169.00 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 30.0 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim





High Preset, 1920x1080, 8xAA, Ultra FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 106.0 165.63 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 64.0 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Metro: Last Light - Benchmark





Very High, 1920x1080, SSAA, DX11 FPS Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 33.78 198.12 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 17.05 100.00 %
More is better





Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Grand Theft Auto V






Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Power Consumption





Power Consumption Idle* Watts Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 48 84.21 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 57 100.00 %
*Entire system Less is better


Power Consumption Load (FurMark)* Watts Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 320 131.15 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 244 100.00 %
*Entire system Less is better






Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Performance Index, price

  Index
AMD Radeon R9 280X 167.28 %
AMD Radeon HD 6970 100.00 %
More is better


  Geizhals Toppreise
AMD Radeon R9 280X Toppreise.ch
AMD Radeon HD 6970 est. EUR 130 eBay  
 


Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdown
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion
[pagebreak]

Conclusion

Comparing the Radeon R9 280X with the Radeon HD 6970 shows us a rather clear result. Looking at performance differences a bit closer shows, that the R9 280X is about 67 percent faster on average than the Radeon HD 6970, when it comes to ingame performance. The biggest performance differences can be found with Battlefield 3, in this case, frame rates are about 114 percent higher on a Radeon HD 6970. On the other side there is the Crysis 3, where the R9 280X is 32.9 percent quicker.

At this point we also want to have a closer look at power consumption. If we equip our test system with a Radeon HD 6970 we see that it pulls 57 Watts from the plug, whereas the same setup with a R9 280X only needs 48 Watt. Under load conditions there is also a rather big difference between the two cards. Once we plugged the Radeon HD 6970 card into the test system power consumption goes up to 244 Watt and with the R9 280X power consumption is at 320 Watt. In this case it looks like the new card is more energy efficient in idle but on the other hand the old card, needs 76 Watts less than the new one under load conditions.

The new Radeon R9 280X is on average almost 70 percent quicker thatn the Radeon HD 6970, which makes this conclusion a no-brainer. Upgrading from the HD 6970 to a R9 280X definitely makes sense and quite a few games get playable again at high resolutions. Other than that you might want to consider, that thanks to the mining hype, Radeon HD 6970 cards go for about 130 Euro on eBay easily. Keeping in mind that an R9 280X card with reference design costs roughly 270 Euro these days will make you invest another 140 Euro to get a really quick, new card.


Page 1 - Introduction Page 10 - DIRT Showdownn
Page 2 - Test Setup Page 11 - Far Cry 3
Page 3 - 3DMark Fire Strike Page 12 - Sleeping Dogs
Page 4 - Unigine Heaven 4.0 Page 13 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Page 5 - BattleField 3 Page 14 - Metro: Last Light
Page 6 - Borderlands 2 Page 15 - GTA V
Page 7 - Bioshock Infinite Page 16 - Power Consumption
Page 8 - Crysis 3 Page 17 - Performance Index, price
Page 9 - Call of Duty Black Ops 2 Page 18 - Conclusion